Wigmore vs. Rumpole
“The very nature of a trial is [the] search for truth.” Nix v. Whiteside, 374 U.S. 157, 158 (1986).
“Cross-examination is the greatest legal engine ever invented for the discovery of truth.” John H. Wigmore, quoted in Lilly v. Virginia, 527 U.S. 116 (1999).
“A criminal trial is a pretty blunt instrument for prising out the truth.” Horace Rumple in John Mortimer’s “Rumpole for the Prosecution,” The Second Rumpole Omnibus.
In the debate between John Mortimer and Horace Rumpole on the one side and John H. Wigmore and the Supreme Court on the other, Mortimer and Rumpole make the better point. Cross-examination can be helpful in ferreting out falsehood, but it doesn’t work too well at discovering truth. The advocate should have a pretty good idea of what the truth is before the trial begins, and the trial should be an exercise in disclosing known truth rather than discovering unknown truth. In Cross-Examination Handbook we teach a method for using cross-examination to effectively disclose the truth we already know to the judge and jury. This should be the first objective of cross-examination, with the exposure of falsehood a secondary objective.
Cross-examination is a useful tool in the advocate’s toolkit, but it is like any other tool. A hammer can be used to perform the useful task of driving nails or used to perform the wrongful task of bashing in someone’s skull. Cross-examination can perform the useful task of disclosing truth or used for the tasks of obscuring the truth and even promoting falsehood. A possible example of this comes from the cross-examination of one of the handwriting experts in the Lindbergh kidnapping case.
The examiners described a number of similarities between the handwriting on the ransom notes and the handwriting of Richard Hauptmann. One of those similarities was that in both the ransom notes and Hauptman’s known writings, “New York” was hyphenated (“New-York”). One of the examiners said that he’d never seen anyone hyphenate “New York.” On cross-examination the defense showed him a number of letters and postcards which purportedly were addressed “New-York.” Each letter and postcard was dutifully marked for identification, and the cross-examination seemed to discredit the examiner. After all, hadn’t the defense shown that “New York” was hyphenated in numerous other documents? No, as a matter of law, they hadn’t.
The procedure for putting a document into evidence is to identify it and authenticate it and then proffer it into evidence as an evidentiary exhibit. During the state’s case in chief, the defense is not technically able to introduce tangible evidence. But they can mark tangible objects for identification, have witnesses identify and authenticate those tangible objects on cross-examination, and then proffer the tangible objects into evidence on the defense case after the state rests. Until the tangible object is received into evidence, the proof is incomplete. If the tangible object is never received into evidence, there is no proof at all, and the testimony about the object can be stricken from the record, if not from the jurors’ minds.
The defense identified the letters and postcards with the state’s documents examiner, but they never authenticated them with the testimony of the people who purportedly wrote or received the correspondence, and they never offered the documents into evidence. They offered no legal proof that anyone besides Richard Hauptmann had ever hyphenated “New-York.” On the state of the evidence as presented by the defense, you would not be justified in believing that they had proved it was common for other people to hyphenate “New York.” But you might be justified in assuming that the cross-examination was smoke and mirrors designed to mislead the jury.
The mere asking of a question is an assertion of fact by the questioner, and by asking the questions, the defense was asserting the fact that they had numerous authentic letters and postcards which had “New York” hyphenated. The ABA’s Model Rule of Professional Conduct 3.3(a)(3) prohibits lawyers from offering false evidence. The ABA’s Prosecution Standard 3-5.7(d) is even more specific: “A prosecutor should not ask a question which implies the existence of a factual predicate for which a good faith belief is lacking.” Before you say “Oh, that only applies to the prosecution,” look at the ABA’s Defense Standard 4-7.6(d): “Defense counsel should not ask a question which implies the existence of a factual predicate for which a good faith belief is lacking.”
If you ask a question which suggests a fact to the jury, you have an obligation to follow that question up with a proffer of proof of that fact. Otherwise you expose yourself to the accusation that you have implied a fact which you do not in good faith believe. Hauptmann’s defense team should have either offered the documents into evidence or they should not have asked the questions which implied a “fact” they had no intention of proving.
cialis vs levitra cialis australia online stores https://goesuscialis.com/
Tadacip optumrx pharmacy pharmacy store usa
cialis to buy how long does cialis last cialis medication
cialis free canada canadian pharmacy no prescription generic cialis cialis for sale canada
india viagra tablets how much is viagra viagra 100mg tabs
viagra without prescription uk viagra uk where to buy sildenafil nz pharmacy
cialis sale online viagra no prescription cialis brand cialis https://pocialgo.com/
sildenafil citrate rules for taking prescription drugs on airplane pharmacy online track order https://mgpharmmg.com/
cialis sublingual paypal cialis cialis free sample https://ciallsed.com/
viagra us sildenafil cost 100mg 20 mg sildenafil 30 tablets cost https://zenviagrok.com/
cv writing services london buy paper online term paper services https://papermelanin.com/
thesis format 3 part thesis apa thesis citation https://thesisabcd.com/
residences at thesis what is a thesis what are the components of a thesis statement https://thesismetre.com/
what is thesis when writing a media response essay, ensure that your thesis statement where should a thesis statement appear https://thesismelon.com/
need help with paper cheap writing service seo article writing service https://paperabbrs.com/
how to write abstract for thesis cause and effect essay thesis how to write acknowledgements for thesis
buy literature review paper best professional cv writing services writing services company
why umich essay how to write a hook for an essay mla essay heading
what does a thesis look like thesis statement? how long is a phd thesis
informative essay outline how to write a definition essay argumentative essay ideas
how to start a compare and contrast essay essay mla format essay corrector
how to write rhetorical analysis essay compare and contrast essay examples for college counterclaim in an argumentative essay
college essay word limit sat essay tips synthesis essay example
generic viagra 200 sildenafil 100mg online india where do you buy viagra
price comparison tadalafil tadalafil combitic buy cialis cheap fast delivery
20 mg sildenafil cheap sildenafil medication viagra 100 mg tablet buy online
descriptive essay the great gatsby essay college essay header
no essay scholarship hook in essay plagiarism essay
sildenafil online australia indian viagra online cheap viagra canadian pharmacy
where to purchase viagra how to get viagra in canada 50 mg viagra price
indian viagra sildenafil coupon 100 mg female viagra buy australia
viagra for women online sildenafil 20 mg price comparison how much is the cost of viagra
buy generic cialis australia best time to take cialis 5mg tadalafil online reviews
blak cialis cialis free trial buy cialis australia
sildenafil 2.5 viagra price in india online purchase female viagra 100mg tablet price in india
cheaper alternative to cialis best research tadalafil tadalafil buy online
what is the difference between cialis and tadalafil? cialis and viagra taken together lilly tadalafil 20 mg
generic cialis india best liquid tadalafil 2018 cialis online canadian pharmacy
levitra discount code buy levitra from india cost of levitra without insurance
generic cialis 20 mg from india where to buy generic cialis? tadalafil 40
cialis dosage for bph wholesale viagra cialis black cialis canadian
buy cialis and receive in 48 hrs cialis order online generic cialis reviews
pharmaceutical online best canadian pharmacy reviews pharmacy cheap
canadian border pharmacy nps online pharmacy reviews insulin from canadian pharmacies
pill identification metformin patrick holford metformin metformin mepha 500
furosemide iv to po conversion lasix order furosemide renal failure
canadian neighbor pharmacy reviews cheapest canada drugs pharmacy technician class online
can you drink alcohol while taking flagyl flagyl pet side effects of flagyl iv
septra bactrim will bactrim treat strep septra and bactrim
can you take norvasc and atenolol atenolol urination atenolol beta 1 blocker
verstopfung bei tamoxifen nolvadex cost do i need tamoxifen after a mastectomy
furosemide lasix 20 mg tablet furosemide ointment lasix weight gain
trazodone hcl 50 mg how does trazodone work for sleep ic trazodone
flagyl dosage 500 mg natural substitute flagyl c diff flagyl how long
bactrim rash reaction bactrim for shingles oral bioavailability bactrim
atenolol and dextromethorphan atenolol dosis endovenosa atenolol dosage for hypertension
glucophage off label uses glucophage birth defects normal dosage for glucophage
will nolvadex cause acne gynecomastia cure nolvadex buy nolvadex amazon
furosemide 12.5mg furosemide furosemide 20 mg uses
can trazodone kill you trazodone as sleeping aid trazodone 50 mg uses
what drug class is gabapentin gabapentin maalox neurontin 400mg side effects
dangers of drinking while taking metronidazole metronidazole dose tooth infection metronidazole gel for pregnant women
can u get pregnant while taking valtrex okay to take valtrex while pregnant valacyclovir transmission study
adverse effect of pregabalin lyrica for nerve pain get high on lyrica
is levoxyl and synthroid the same monthly cost of synthroid biaxin and synthroid
gabapentin 500 mg price buy gabapentin 800 mg cost of gabapentin 800 mg
side effects lisinopril how much lisinopril is too much hydrochlorothiazide over the counter
atorvastatin calcium classification what is the drug atorvastatin used for what is atorvastatin
glucophage for type 1 pre diabetes glucophage glucophage 500 dzialanie
mechanism of action furosemide drug interactions with furosemide furosemide diuretico
nolvadex igf nolvadex pct alcohol buy nolvadex review
dosage range of atenolol tenormin eccipienti atenolol en urgencias
goodrx trazodone is trazodone anticholinergic shelf life of trazodone
gabapentin 300 prescription price for neurontin neurontin online pharmacy
dangers of taking metronidazole anaerobes sensitive to metronidazole metronidazole in young puppies
simvastatin to atorvastatin atorvastatin manufacturer coupons atorvastatin price walmart
can you take birth control while on synthroid converting synthroid to naturethroid how to determine synthroid dosage
hello!,I like your writing very a lot! proportion we keep in touch
extra approximately your article on AOL? I need an expert on this area to resolve my problem.
Maybe that is you! Looking ahead to peer you.
Hello from Indonesia, Regards, IDProperti.com | Pasang Iklan Properti